She walked toward them.
Reviewers note the book is written in a simple, "dry like a judgement" but deeply thoughtful and "serene" manner. It is composed of short, accessible chapters designed to be a quick yet impactful read. Reference Details Author: Hans Raj Khanna Publisher: Eastern Book Company Original Publication: 1985 neither roses nor thorns pdf
The book details the aftermath of his dissent—being superseded for the Chief Justice of India post and his subsequent resignation. She walked toward them
The gardener appeared beside her, silent as ever. "What do you see?" Reference Details Author: Hans Raj Khanna Publisher: Eastern
A significant portion of the book focuses on the Habeas Corpus case, which is the defining moment of Justice Khanna's career. The core issue was whether a citizen's right to approach a court for enforcement of their fundamental rights (specifically the right to life and liberty) could be suspended during a national emergency. While the government argued that it could, Justice Khanna, in his dissent, famously held: In other words, he asserted that the government could not simply wish away fundamental rights.
In an era where fundamental rights were suspended, Justice Khanna stood virtually alone in upholding the right to life and personal liberty. His stance cost him the position of Chief Justice of India, a customary promotion he was passed over for due to his dissenting opinion. Yet, he never wavered. In an editorial, The New York Times famously noted: "If India ever finds its way back to freedom and democracy that proud hallmark of its first 18 years, someone will surely erect a monument to Justice H.R. Khanna of the Supreme Court".